Parable of the Ketchup

“Parable of the Ketchup,” Friend, Apr. 1999, 32


Parable of the Ketchup

Though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow (Isa. 1:18).

Carrie hurried around the corner of the grocery store aisle, trying to keep the cart out of the reach of her six-year-old brother, Andy.

“No fair!” he cried. “You’ve pushed it the whole time we’ve been here.” He tried to grab the cart, but nine-year-old Carrie twisted it away quickly, accidentally hitting a row of ketchup bottles lined up neatly on a shelf. Two of the bottles crashed to the floor, shattering and spraying the bright red contents everywhere. The two children stared in horror at the broken glass and scarlet ketchup.

Mom came around the corner just then, saying, “I want you two to stay with me. …” Her words trailed off as she saw the mess on the floor and the misery on Carrie and Andy’s faces.

“It looks like there’s been an accident,” she said. “It’s all right. Sometimes things break and have to be cleaned up. There’s no use crying over spilt ketchup.”

Mom found a clerk, who cleaned up the mess without getting mad at Carrie or Andy. Carrie still felt terrible. She knew it wouldn’t have happened if she hadn’t been swinging the cart to keep it away from Andy. Before they left the store, she quietly told Mom how the bottles had been broken. Mom listened solemnly while Andy stood with a scared expression on his face.

“Are we in trouble?” Andy asked, struggling to keep from crying.

Mom hugged Andy. “No, I think you feel badly enough about what happened that you’ll be more careful in the grocery store from now on. But, Carrie, what do you think you need to do to make up for the store losing those two bottles of ketchup?”

“I think I need to pay for them. I didn’t mean to break them, but it was still my fault.”

“I think that’s a good idea,” Mom said. “I can lend you the money for now, and you can pay me back at home.”

At the cash register, Mom explained that Carrie had been playing around with the cart when the bottles broke, and so she wanted to pay for them. The clerk thanked Carrie for being so honest, and Carrie felt much better.

At home, Carrie didn’t feel quite as good when she gave Mom part of the money she’d been saving for a tape player, but she was still glad she didn’t have that sick feeling in her stomach that she had felt when the bottles exploded on the floor. She remembered how red everything looked. She had been afraid she would see that stain on the floor forever, reminding her of her mistake, but it had come clean with a wet mop.

A few months later, Carrie finished Sunday dinner and flopped down on the couch with a big sigh.

“What’s the matter, sweetheart?” Mom asked. “That’s a pretty heavy sigh for a Sunday afternoon.”

“Mom, I have to give a talk in Primary next Sunday on Jesus’ Atonement. I’m not even sure I know what the Atonement is.”

“This sounds like a good Sunday activity,” Mom said, sitting on the couch next to Carrie. “Why don’t you tell me what you do know?”

Carrie was quiet for a moment, then replied, “I think it’s when Jesus suffered for our sins. If we repent, we don’t have to suffer any more for them because He already did. Then we can be forgiven.”

“Good!” Mom said, squeezing Carrie’s arm warmly. “You understand a lot. Tell me about being forgiven. What does that mean?”

“Well, I guess it means that we’re not in trouble anymore.” Carrie thought some more. “I mean, Heavenly Father doesn’t hold it against us. He forgives us, and we can forget about what happened.”

“Do we forget completely?” Mom asked quickly.

“Well, no—we have to remember never to do that wrong thing again. And we have to try to make up for what we did, like me apologizing to Andy if I yell at him or something. But once we’re forgiven, we don’t have to keep feeling bad anymore. But, Mom,” Carrie asked, “how do I explain this so the little kids get it? The three-year-olds are going to be totally lost!”

Mom was excited, her eyes twinkling. “Do you think they’d like a flannel-board story?”

“Sure! But how can I do that for the Atonement?”

“Think ketchup,” Mom said mysteriously.

Carrie looked at her in confusion, then cried, “Perfect!” as she bounced off the couch and hurried into the kitchen for paper, pencils, and construction paper. Carrie worked on her talk all afternoon, cutting out figures and thinking about her story.

Next week even the Sunbeams forgot to wiggle in their chairs as Carrie gave her talk. She put up a cut-out shape of a ketchup bottle, then the broken container with a big pool of red below it. The children were obviously shocked by the thought of breaking a whole bottle of bright red ketchup. Carrie explained, “We can make mistakes that seem too horrible to be forgiven, but if we repent, our spirits can become clean from sin, just as ketchup can be mopped up off a floor.” She took down the picture of the broken bottle, and replaced it with a picture of a sparkling clean floor.

“It’s kind of like how Jesus helps us ‘clean up’ when we commit a sin and we’re truly sorry and try to repair the damage we’ve done. He has suffered for our sins, so we don’t have to keep feeling guilty and bad forever. He helps us feel good again after we repent.”

She ended her talk with a scripture from the Bible, explaining that even if our sins are like scarlet, we can become white as snow through repentance, because of the Atonement.

As Carrie sat down, she looked at Mom sitting on the back row of the Primary room. Mom winked, and Carrie smiled back. This was the best talk she’d ever given. Maybe the rest of the family would like a repeat for family home evening!

Illustrated by Mark Robison